Understanding Ambiguous Wills in NSW: What to Do When Your Loved One's Will Is Unclear

Challenging a Will

When a loved one passes away, dealing with their final wishes as outlined in their will should provide some closure during a difficult time. However, poorly written or unclear wills can create confusion and family disputes that add stress to an already challenging situation.

If you're struggling to understand what your loved one meant in their will, you're not alone. This guide explains what steps you can take and how NSW courts handle unclear wills.

What to Do When You Don't Understand a Will

Start by Speaking With the Executor

If you have concerns about unclear language in your loved one's will, your first step should be to discuss these concerns with the executor. Often, family members and beneficiaries can reach an agreement about what the unclear section means without needing legal intervention.

Resolving disagreements through family discussion can save everyone time, money, and emotional stress during an already difficult period.

Get Legal Advice Early

If family discussions don't resolve the confusion, it's important to contact a wills and probate lawyer as soon as possible. This applies whether you're a concerned beneficiary or an executor who can't make sense of the will's instructions.

Early legal advice helps you understand your options and the best approach for dealing with unclear language in the will.

Consider Mediation

Mediation offers a way to resolve will disputes without going to court. In mediation, all parties work with a neutral mediator to negotiate a mutually acceptable solution.

Your lawyer can help you understand whether mediation might work for your situation and explain the benefits and potential drawbacks.

How NSW Courts Interpret Unclear Wills

The Court's Primary Goal

When a will's meaning is disputed in NSW courts, judges focus on determining what the person who made the will (the testator) actually intended based on the written words. The court looks at the will as a whole document rather than isolated phrases.

However, courts can only work with what's actually written in the will or clearly implied by the language used. They cannot add intentions that aren't expressed in the document itself.

When Courts Can Consider External Evidence

Under Section 32 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), courts can consider evidence about the testator's intentions if:

• The will's language is meaningless

• The language is clearly ambiguous on its face

• The language becomes ambiguous when considered alongside surrounding circumstances

It's important to understand that a will isn't considered "ambiguous" simply because it's difficult to interpret. For courts to admit external evidence, the unclear words or phrases must have multiple possible meanings that could reasonably apply.

What Happens If the Ambiguity Can't Be Resolved

If the court cannot determine what unclear language in a will means, that part of the will may be declared invalid. When this happens, the affected assets are treated as part of the residual estate (the remainder after specific gifts are distributed).

If there's no clear instruction for the residual estate, these assets are distributed according to NSW intestacy laws - the legal rules that determine inheritance when someone dies without a valid will.

Getting Help with Unclear Wills in NSW

Understanding what your loved one meant in their will shouldn't add to your grief. If you're dealing with confusing or ambiguous language in a will, professional legal guidance can help you navigate this challenging situation.

BOOK AN APPOINTMENT